You updated your password.

Reset Password

Enter the email address you used to create your account. We will email you instructions on how to reset your password.

Reset Password Modal Form

Forgot Your Email Address? Contact Us

Tools of Thinking: Understanding the World through Experience and Reason

Cut through deception and faulty reasoning to get closer to the essence of a matter.

Guidebook
 
 
What Are “Tools of Thinking”?

01: What Are “Tools of Thinking”?

The “tools of thinking” are the devices and processes we use to achieve knowledge. This lecture introduces eight tools: experience, memory, association, pattern discernment and recognition, reason, invention, experimentation, and intuition.

Which Tools of Thinking Are Basic?

02: Which Tools of Thinking Are Basic?

Professor Hall discusses the eight tools of thinking in detail. Reason, experience, invention, and experimentation are particularly important, since we use them to create our languages and make our instruments of investigation.

Platonic Intuition, Memory, and Reason

03: Platonic Intuition, Memory, and Reason

Plato subordinated sense experience to the tools of intuition, memory, and reason, believing that knowledge results from uncovering what the mind already knows intuitively.

Intuition, Memory, and Reason—Problems

04: Intuition, Memory, and Reason—Problems

We explore some of the major problems with Plato's reliance on intuition, memory, and reason. Even though Plato's position makes good use of several basic tools of thinking, it is still inadequate.

Sense Experience—A More Modern Take

05: Sense Experience—A More Modern Take

What we see, taste, smell, feel, hear, and read can be unreliable. That means we must exercise great caution when we use such input as a basis for our thoughts.

Observation and Immediate Inferences

06: Observation and Immediate Inferences

Aristotle recognized the importance of observation. But his primary concern was with what one can rationally infer. This stimulated his interest in the processes and patterns of reason itself, and led to his systematic mapping of what we call logic.

Further Immediate Inferences

07: Further Immediate Inferences

We continue our investigation of Aristotle's logic by looking at what more can be inferred from a single categorical proposition. The “square of opposition” is a powerful arrangement for analyzing immediate inferences that can be drawn from the truth or falsity of a single proposition.

Categorical Syllogisms

08: Categorical Syllogisms

A categorical syllogism consists of three categorical propositions: two premises and a conclusion. We learn how to place a categorical syllogism in standard form and how to analyze it in terms of mood and figure.

Ancient Logic in Modern Dress

09: Ancient Logic in Modern Dress

Some classes have no members; for example, the class of unicorns. This creates problems because we don't always know whether a class is populated or not. We look at how developments by logicians George Boole and John Venn help deal with this issue.

Systematic Doubt and Rational Certainty

10: Systematic Doubt and Rational Certainty

We recapitulate some of the reasons for calling sense experience into question, in light of the “systematic doubt” of the 17th-century philosopher René Descartes.

The Limits of Sense Experience

11: The Limits of Sense Experience

What content for thought does sense experience, by itself, provide? This lecture probes the views of David Hume, who argued that we have no sensations of causation as such, casting doubt on our ability to use inductive reasoning to gain demonstrable truths about the world.

Inferences Demand Relevant Evidence

12: Inferences Demand Relevant Evidence

Inferences that rely on irrelevant “evidence” commit non sequitur in one form or another. In this lecture, we explore descriptions and examples of seven forms that such bad reasoning can take.

Proper Inferences Avoid Equivocation

13: Proper Inferences Avoid Equivocation

In relying on experiences as evidence for our inferences, we must avoid making unwarranted presumptions. Otherwise, we may be guilty of fallacies of presumption and ambiguity - eight examples of which are given.

Induction Is Slippery but Unavoidable

14: Induction Is Slippery but Unavoidable

After making a pragmatic assumption about the regularity of nature, we look at John Stuart Mill's classic analysis of the inductive methods of agreement, difference, residues and concomitant variation. These are illustrated with examples to help clarify what induction can do and what it can't.

The Scientific Revolution

15: The Scientific Revolution

Focusing on the methods and ideas of Isaac Newton, we explore three factors that are essential for the generation of a prediction, which is the hallmark of modern science.

Hypotheses and Experiments—A First Look

16: Hypotheses and Experiments—A First Look

Irresponsible hypothesis construction is hard to distinguish from mere speculation. Responsible hypotheses are grounded in testing and experimentation. Hypotheses that are grounded and confirmed in this way generate covering laws.

How Empirical Is Modern Empiricism?

17: How Empirical Is Modern Empiricism?

Direct observations and inferences generated from them are possible at the macro level. However, a different kind of empirical link is required at the micro level where direct observation is impossible. In that case, hypotheses must be constructed and inferences from them need only be confirmed by empirical observation. This opens the door to theoretical imagination, creativity, and conceptual invention.

Hypotheses and Experiments—A Closer Look

18: Hypotheses and Experiments—A Closer Look

There are at least two uses for experiments that are of interest to modern rational empiricists. Some are aimed at discovering patterns that will help generate descriptive and explanatory knowledge. Others are aimed at testing the theories that we entertain, so as to confirm or disconfirm them.

“Normal Science” at Mid-Century

19: “Normal Science” at Mid-Century

In the middle of the 20th century, the vision of “normal science” was rooted in the movement called logical positivism, with contributions by logicians, mathematicians, scientists, and philosophers.

Modern Logic—Truth Tables

20: Modern Logic—Truth Tables

Whether we hypothesize, discover, or create the mathematics, covering laws, and state descriptions that we use in explaining what we observe, we need a reliable apparatus for drawing inferences from them. This is provided by modern logic.

Modern Logic—Sentential Arguments

21: Modern Logic—Sentential Arguments

We continue our examination of the techniques of modern logic used in complex derivations, with a look at replacement rules, such as DeMorgan's theorems, and rules of inference, such as modus ponens.

Modern Logic—Predicate Arguments

22: Modern Logic—Predicate Arguments

In contrast to sentential logic, which treats simple sentences as unanalyzed units, predicate logic involves the analysis of the internal structure of subject/predicate sentences. We look at the tools that allow us to solve predicate arguments far beyond the scope of Aristotelian syllogistic.

Postmodern and New-Age Problems

23: Postmodern and New-Age Problems

Modern rational empiricism is not problem-free. For instance, we know that observations themselves are theory laden. Further, if the general culture determines what those ideas and theories are, then even our simplest descriptions are culturally relative. These are central themes of postmodernism.

Rational Empiricism in the 21st Century

24: Rational Empiricism in the 21st Century

The tools of thinking are available to all. There are useful places to put them to use if we will spend the efforts to master them. The systematic study of logic, science, mathematics, history, and even philosophy, are all good places to start.

Overview Course No. 4413

Everyone has to think in order to function in the world, but what is the best way to reason effectively in your pursuit of reliable beliefs and useful knowledge? What is the best way to prove a case, create a rule, solve a problem, justify an idea, invent a hypothesis, or evaluate an argument? In short, what is the best way to think? Professor Hall helps you cut through deception and faulty reasoning in these 24 humorous, clear, and interesting lectures, offering a friendly but intellectually rigorous approach to the problem of thinking. Among the topics you'll learn about are:

  • Deduction (this form of reasoning reaches a conclusion based on a set of premises; if the premises are true, then the conclusion necessarily follows)
  • Induction (less ironclad than deduction, this approach surveys the evidence and then generalizes an explanation to account for it; the conclusion may be probable, but it is not certain)
  • Syllogism (this simple but powerful deductive argument offers two premises and a conclusion, e.g., “All Greeks are mortals. All Athenians are Greeks. Therefore, all Athenians are mortals.”)
  • Dialectic (a question-and-answer dialogue, called dialectic, is valuable for uncovering first principles)
  • Venn diagrams (this technique uses overlapping circles to represent different classes of objects or ideas in order to clarify a syllogism)

Some of the greatest philosophers who ever lived have used these tools to separate ideas that make sense from those that don't. Now you, too, can think more clearly, making better lives for ourselves and for those to come.

About

James Hall

Philosophy is reflecting on why you think what you think, believe what you believe, and do what you do. Anyone can do it. Everyone should.

INSTITUTION
University of Richmond

Dr. James Hall is the James Thomas Professor of Philosophy, Emeritus, at the University of Richmond, where he taught for 40 years. He earned his B.A. from Johns Hopkins University, his Master of Theology from Southeastern Theological Seminary, and his Ph.D. from The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. At the University of Richmond, Professor Hall was named Omicron Delta Kappa Faculty Member of the Year (2005) and Student Government Association Faculty Member of the Year (2005), and he received the University Distinguished Educator Award (2001). He has written many articles and essays and is the author of three books: Knowledge, Belief and Transcendence; Logic Problems; and Practically Profound: Putting Philosophy to Work in Everyday Life. Professor Hall specializes in 20th-century analytic philosophy, epistemology, logical empiricism, and the philosophy of religion. At Richmond, he was noted for developing cross-disciplinary courses combining physics, chemistry, economics, psychology, and literature with his own field of philosophy.

By This Professor